Are Shock Collars Cruel | Does It Hurt Your Dog

Does It Hurt Your Dog
Spread the love

The use of shock collars for dogs is a topic of debate among trainers, veterinarians, and animal welfare experts. Some people believe they are a useful training method for keeping your furry partner from barking or stopping bad behavior while others strongly believe they are really cruel and unnecessary.

Now, let me answer the question, Are shock collars Cruel? Does it hurt your dog? Ecollar is not designed to cause harm or hurt to your dog if used correctly. So, it is cruel when you use it the right way on your furry friend.

Using shock collars as a method of training your furry friend is called “positive punishment.” This simply means that these collars work by encouraging your pet to avoid punishment through shock.

Side Effects Of Shock Collars

Electric collar has side effects on your dog when it is not used properly, these are the dangers as follows:

  1. Physical Pain and Discomfort
  2. Fear and Anxiety
  3. Aggression
  4. Decreased Trust and Bonding:
  5. Inhibition of Natural Behaviors
  6. Stress
  7. Might Escalation of  bad Behavioral
  8. Confusion

Do Vets Recommend Shock Collars?

Do Vets Recommend Shock Collars for dogs

It will be very hard to see a vet who will recommend it. The Australian Veterinary Association (AVA) has made a very bold statement on the use of ‘shock collars’; and they are illegal in three states of Australia. The AVA protocols help in shaping the views of Aussie veterinarians. So for this one reason. Many vets won’t recommend the use of these collars to their clients.

There have been many studies on the use of ‘ecollars’ for puppies training and they have different results. The shock may lead to pain and fear, which is demonstrated by your furry friend through yelping, cowering, lowering of hair and submissive postures. Electric collars can result in a negative association with owners. One study showed that when you use it correctly they do not increase stress hormone.

Although it is believed that ‘shock collars’ when used in the right way can reduce problem behaviors, it still does not need to be used in most cases.

Related>>> Do Dogs like wearing collar?

Are Shock Collars Good For Dogs?

Just as we had explained above, e collar is good for stopping bad behavior in your dog when used properly.  Misuse will lead expose your pup to the dangers listed above. However, positive reinforcement-based training methods, such as treats, praise, and consistent training and socialization, are a more effective and humane way to address unwanted behaviors in dogs according to Tryfi.

See>>> Are Collars Bad For Dogs

Can A Shock Collar Kill A Dog?

can shock collar kill or hurt your dog

Yes, there have been some cases where e-collars have been associated with the death of dogs but this rarely happens. The main situation that might lead to severe outcomes, fatalities or even death comes from the misuse of shock collars or using them at high levels of intensity.

They are not designed to kill dogs when used correctly. They are designed with safety in mind, and the level of stimulation can be adjusted to make sure that they don’t pose any life-threatening risks to your furry friend.

However, they can kill small dogs, especially those weighing less than 8 pounds because they can not withstand the shock.


Electric collars are not cruel or hurt your dog if they are used correctly.

Images from

Leave a Comment